|
$13.99 CD
$14.99 LP
| |
BONNIE 'PRINCE' BILLY
Sings Greatest Palace Music
(Drag City)
|
"New Partner" |
|
"Agnes, Queen of Sorrow" |
Unless you simply don't care for Will Oldham's whole thing, you
must admit that the concept behind this new record is intriguing.
Oldham, an indie-rock iconoclast if there ever was one, has put
his country singer-songwriter status to the acid test: he assembled
a band of top-notch Nashville studio musicians (including legendary
pianist Hargus Robbins, who has worked with George Jones, Patsy
Cline, Loretta Lynn, Dolly Parton, Bob Dylan, Ray Charles and
many, many more), and did a classic greatest-hits redux package.
Fans voted for their favorite tracks of the Palace years, and
Oldham made straight country versions of his quirky, off-kilter
classics. Firmly in the tradition of his country music forebears,
this second chance at the hits of your own past (or of an influential
hero, if you take the concept of the Bonnie Prince covering Palace
Music at face value) is an age-old move in the genre, as aging
artists try to reclaim chart position or drifting fans. And while
fans of Oldham's surely love his quavering and cracking vocal
delivery and seemingly spontaneous studio productions at least
as much as they do his haunting songwriting, he has stepped out
of his element and seemingly tried to mainstream his songs, with
sometimes exhilarating, yet ultimately mixed results.
There are two ways to look at the changes wrought on the Palace
catalog; the Oldham Optimist will be thrilled by what has been
added to these stark compositions. Lovely pedal steel, tinkling
piano, soaring fiddle and mandolin, and vocal harmonies the like
the Bonnie Prince has never heard. The musicians are subtle and
experienced, and their gentle re-workings of these simple tunes
can often shed new light on what may have originally appeared
as an intensely personal wail. The Palace Pessimist, however,
is bound to be disappointed by what's been taken away; it's harder
to quantify, but I think the loss can be summed up in a word:
passion. There are many high points within the 15 tracks, but
many also suffer from a mysterious lack of emotion. And the main
culprit may be Oldham himself. Perhaps in an attempt to fit in
with the level, measured tone of the new arrangements, his vocals
often seem almost an afterthought. He has wiped his delivery clean
of the warble for which he is known, but there is not much here
to replace it. He simply doesn't have the depth of voice to deliver
passionate straight versions of his songs; just listen to the
duets for crystal illumination of this fact. When Marty Slayton,
a stunning Dolly Parton sound-alike, takes the her chorus on "Agnes,
Queen of Sorrow", Oldham's flat delivery is left in the cold,
as her warm and emotional soprano takes center stage. Although
there are highlights throughout, the overall album seems both
slick and dull, and I'm left wondering if any of the musicians
involved, Oldham included, felt much connection to the songs or
these versions.
For a record containing no new material performed by musicians
for hire, this is nonetheless a remarkably ambitious album by
a vital and important artist. And it is also an important album
in the Oldham discography, and one that I think any longtime fan
needs to spend some time with, and which will likely provide many
hours of interest. But in many ways I feel that the Bonnie Prince
has missed the point of his own experiment, or maybe just failed.
I'm far from certain that Oldham really put his best foot forward
here
I'm sure he is far more calculating that I give him
credit for, but he seems just a bit out of his element here, and
uninspired by the challenge that he gave himself. I took this
to be a well-earned shot by Oldham to answer an age-old what-if:
what-if the prince was a pauper and the pauper a prince? What
if a left-field artist like Will Oldham had taken a different
route and sold his classic rooted songs to a mainstream palate
instead of willfully courting the fringe? If this were meant as
an answer, I'd like to posit a different question: Is Will just
messing with us again? As usual, he raises more questions than
answers, and perhaps that's the point after all. [JM]
| |